Skip to main content

Houston, Texas · Serving all 50 states + DC

Independent property insurance appraisal and umpire services across the country.

When the amount of loss is disputed, REG Consulting provides independent appraisal and umpire services to help the parties reach a documented, binding award through the policy appraisal process.

REG is based in the Houston area and works across Texas and nationwide. See our service areas

  • IAUA Member
  • NAIIA Member
  • Xactimate Certified
  • 1000+ Valuations
  • Texas Adjuster Lic. No. 2313825
1,000+property valuations completedvaluations completed
50 + DCstates and the District of Columbia, with each state's rules belowstates and DC
5.0 Google rating from 15 reviewsGoogle rating, 15 reviews
  • IAUA Certified Property Insurance Appraiser
  • NAIIA member
  • Xactimate certified
  • Texas licensed adjuster · No. 2313825
  • Se habla español

Section I, Conditions

The answer is already in the policy.

Most property policies carry an appraisal condition. When the parties disagree on the amount of loss, either one may demand appraisal in writing. Each names an appraiser, an umpire breaks any tie between them, and any two of the three can sign a binding award.

See it step by step

The sheet is an illustration that paraphrases a standard homeowners form. Wording and deadlines vary by policy and by state.

REG Consulting, LLCis a Texas property insurance appraisal and umpire firm serving the Houston area, including The Woodlands, Conroe, Magnolia, Spring, Cypress, Katy, Sugar Land, Pearland, and surrounding Texas markets. The firm provides independent property insurance appraisal services, umpire resolution, Xactimate estimate review, and claim consulting to property owners, insurance carriers, attorneys, contractors, and public adjusters. REG Consulting specializes in roof system disputes, interior water damage, hail and wind claims, estimate reconciliation, depreciation analysis, and appraisal panel negotiations. Rene Goodall, the firm's principal, is a Texas Licensed Independent Adjuster with 1000+ valuations completed nationally, IAUA member (Insurance Appraisals and Umpire Association), NAIIA member, and Xactimate-certified estimator.

If you and we fail to agree on the amount of loss, either may demand an appraisal.

The claim is accepted. The number is what's disputed.

That's the problem the appraisal clause exists to solve. It rarely starts with a denial. It starts with two scopes that don't match, a partial payment, or a file that stops moving.

The two estimates are far apart.

Whether it's the insurer's number or a contractor's bid, a gap in scope, quantity and price is exactly what appraisal decides.

A payment was issued and the claim went quiet.

Accepting a payment doesn't automatically end the right to dispute the amount, though the policy and your state's rules apply.

The file was closed with the amount still disputed.

If the carrier accepted the loss, the amount can usually still go to appraisal.

A bid sits far above the documented scope, or supplements keep coming.

When repeated supplements can't be settled line by line, appraisal gives both sides a defined way to set the amount.

Reconciliation of estimatesExample · hail loss

6 of 8 settled by the appraisers · 2 sent to the umpire

  • Shingles, front slopesAgreed
    Insurer
    Replace, 18 sq
    Policyholder
    Replace, 18 sq
    Panel
    Replace, 18 sq
  • Shingles, rear slopeAgreed
    Insurer
    Repair, 4 sq
    Policyholder
    Replace, 14 sq
    Panel
    Replace, 14 sq
  • Drip edge & starter courseAgreed
    Insurer
    Not included
    Policyholder
    226 LF
    Panel
    226 LF
  • Gutters, north & eastTo umpire
    Insurer
    Repair, 24 LF
    Policyholder
    Replace, 102 LF
    Panel
    Replace, 62 LF
  • Siding, east elevationTo umpire
    Insurer
    Repair, 40 SF
    Policyholder
    Replace, 640 SF
    Panel
    Repair, 60 SF
  • Ceiling, bedroom 2Agreed
    Insurer
    Paint only
    Policyholder
    Drywall, texture, paint
    Panel
    Paint only
  • Overhead & profitAgreed
    Insurer
    Not applied
    Policyholder
    10% + 10%
    Panel
    10% + 10%
  • Permit & inspectionAgreed
    Insurer
    Per city
    Policyholder
    Per city + re‑inspection
    Panel
    Per city
Line itemInsurer's estimatePolicyholder's estimatePanelResult
Shingles, front slopesInsurer: Replace, 18 sqPolicyholder: Replace, 18 sqPanel: Replace, 18 sqSameAgreed
Shingles, rear slopeInsurer: Repair, 4 sqPolicyholder: Replace, 14 sqPanel: Replace, 14 sqDiffersAgreed
Drip edge & starter courseInsurer: Not includedPolicyholder: 226 LFPanel: 226 LFDiffersAgreed
Gutters, north & eastInsurer: Repair, 24 LFPolicyholder: Replace, 102 LFPanel: Replace, 62 LFDiffersTo umpire
Siding, east elevationInsurer: Repair, 40 SFPolicyholder: Replace, 640 SFPanel: Repair, 60 SFDiffersTo umpire
Ceiling, bedroom 2Insurer: Paint onlyPolicyholder: Drywall, texture, paintPanel: Paint onlyDiffersAgreed
Overhead & profitInsurer: Not appliedPolicyholder: 10% + 10%Panel: 10% + 10%DiffersAgreed
Permit & inspectionInsurer: Per cityPolicyholder: Per city + re‑inspectionPanel: Per cityDiffersAgreed
Settled by the two appraisers: 6 of 8Sent to the umpire: 2

An illustration of a line-by-line comparison in Xactimate, not a record of any real claim. The panel can land on either side, or between them.

The two appraisers will choose an umpire.

One appraiser each. A neutral umpire.

Appraisal isn't a lawsuit and it isn't arbitration. It's a valuation on a clock. Each side names someone who can price the repair, and the umpire decides only what those two can't agree on.

Typical timeline. Deadlines vary by policy and state.

Day 0

Written demand

Either party sends a written appraisal demand that cites the policy condition, usually by certified mail.

Appraisal award · amount of loss

We, the undersigned, appointed under the appraisal condition of the policy, have inspected the property and set the amount of loss below. This award does not decide coverage.

Replacement cost value$41,382.40
Actual cash value$31,862.04
Appraiser for the insured
Appraiser for the insurer
Umpire (not required)
Payment issued per policy terms

Two signatures were enough. In most appraisals the umpire's line stays blank.

A decision agreed to by any two will set the amount of loss.

What the panel settles, and what stays with the courts.

Knowing where that line sits is what makes an award hold up. Stay inside it and the award stands. Cross it and it can be thrown out.

The panel decides

The cost to repair or replace
Materials, labor, unit prices and totals.
The scope of work
Rooms, elevations, materials and quantities.
Repair or replace
Including matching, where the state requires it.
Depreciation and actual cash value
What was held back, and whether it was fair.
Overhead and profit
Whether the job needs a general contractor.

A court decides

Whether the loss is covered at all
Exclusions, conditions and denials.
What the policy language means
Interpretation is a legal question.
Bad faith
And any penalties that come with it.
Deadlines to sue
Appraisal doesn't pause the suit clock in most states.
Interest and attorney's fees
The award states an amount. The rest is for a judge.
Causation sits on the line.

In Texas, Iowa and, once the carrier admits some covered loss, Florida, courts have let the panel weigh what caused the damage while setting the amount of loss. Coverage itself stays with the court.

In Alabama, Mississippi and Tennessee, courts have held that the cause of damage is for the court, not the appraisers. Check your state's rule.

Where the disagreements start

The losses we see most.

Every kind of loss is hard to price in its own way. Hail hides on the slopes you can't see from the street. Water hides behind cabinets. Wind hides in matching. Pick one to see where we look.

Sample footage

Hail

Hail is counted, not guessed: hits per ten-foot test square, on every slope of the roof.

Where estimates tend to differ

  • Every slope inspected, including the ones you can't see from the street
  • Soft metals that show where the stones hit: vents, flashing, gutters
  • Whether brittle shingles can be repaired at all, or have to come off

Among the common losses in Texas, Colorado and Oklahoma.

Service areas

Rooted in Houston. Working across Texas and the country.

REG is based in the Houston area, so most of our on-site work starts close to home. We take assignments across Texas and in every state.

…a judge of a court of record in the state where the property is located.

Almost every policy has the clause. Every state runs it differently.

The rules that apply are those of the state where the property sits, even if the owner is living somewhere else during repairs.

27 states write the clause into law. 19 leave it to the policy form. 3 allow appraisal only when both sides agree. 2 license or register the people who serve.

All state guides
Smaller states:

What we do

Four ways we help settle a claim.

For policyholders, carriers, attorneys and contractors. The same standard on every file.

Property owners

Homeowners & businesses

When the owner and the insurer disagree on the number, independent appraisal gets the amount decided fairly.

Carriers

Insurance carriers

Defensible, impartial valuations, carrier-appointed appraisal and umpire services.

Professionals

Attorneys, adjusters & contractors

Appraisal support, expert testimony and consulting on complex property disputes.

Rene Goodall, principal of REG Consulting
Rene Goodall · Principal, REG Consulting

…each party will choose a competent and impartial appraiser.

Rene Goodall, independent by design.

Rene has completed more than 1,000 property valuations and has been appointed by policyholders and carriers alike. He knows how estimates are built and where scope gets missed on either side, and he handles every file personally, from the first inspection to the signed award.

Licensed independent adjusterTexas Department of Insurance · License No. 2313825
IAUA · CPIACertified Property Insurance Appraiser
NAIIA memberNational Assoc. of Independent Insurance Adjusters
Xactimate certifiedIndustry-standard estimating
5.0★★★★★15 Google reviews

Client Trust

Trusted by property owners and insurance professionals

5.0 · 15 reviews on Google

Real reviews from clients we've served, sourced from REG Consulting's verified Google Business Profile.

“Very knowledgeable and professional. REG will treat you with TLC and maintains constant communication throughout the process. Most importantly takes the lead from the start, prioritizing customer needs to ensure your home is restored as quickly as possible.”

Rodrigo M.

Verified Google Review

“Rene was great to work with! Very grateful for his patience and thorough explanations. He took his time with us and simplified the process as best as possible. Definitely recommend his services.”

Maria M.

Verified Google Review

“It was a really good inspection process — really meticulous and professional. I highly recommend.”

Luciana G.

Verified Google Review

“Personalized, reliable, and tailored service is what distinguishes the company.”

Ana L. D.

Verified Google Review

“Professional, excellent business enterprise. Fully reliable.”

Luis R. M.

Verified Google Review

“Rene provided an independent appraisal that was thorough and detailed. He was professional throughout the entire process and answered all of my questions clearly. Highly satisfied with the outcome.”

James T.

Verified Google Review

All testimonials sourced from verified Google reviews

Credentials & Professional Memberships

IAUA Certified Property Insurance Appraiser

IAUA · CPIA

Certified Property Insurance Appraiser

NAIIA Member

National Assoc. of Independent Insurance Adjusters

Xactimate Certified

Industry-standard estimating platform

Licensed in Texas

Texas Department of Insurance

1000+ Valuations

Completed across the United States

Before you call

Questions people ask us first.

Have these in front of you

  • The whole policy, not only the declarations page
  • Both estimates and every letter since
  • Photos of the damage, the scope of work and any contractor's bid
  • The date of loss and what's been paid so far

Or call (936) 693-3281. Rene answers.

What does an independent appraiser actually do?

We set the amount of loss together with the appraiser the other party appoints. We inspect, document and price the damage line by line in the same software the carrier uses, then work through the differences item by item. Anything we can't agree on goes to the umpire, and under most policies any two signatures set the amount.

Is my claim eligible for appraisal?

Often, yes, including many claims that were partly paid or partly denied. A common example is a storm claim where the interior was paid but the roof was denied as wear and tear, or a roof that was approved for repair when the dispute is over full replacement. How much damage the storm did, and what it takes to fix it, are amount-of-loss questions, and appraisal is built for them. What a panel can't decide is pure coverage, such as an excluded peril or a policy that wasn't in force. How far appraisers may go on cause of damage varies by state, so check your state's guide, and we'll tell you plainly if appraisal doesn't fit.

A payment was already issued. Is it too late?

Often not, but it depends on your policy and your state. Accepting a payment does not by itself usually end the right to dispute the amount, though long delays can cause problems, and in some states a court can find appraisal was waived by unreasonable delay. Watch the policy's deadline to sue as well: in most states, demanding appraisal does not pause it, and a few states do pause it. Your state's guide covers the details.

Do you decide whether the policy covers the loss?

No. Whether the policy covers a kind of loss is a legal question for the courts. The panel decides the amount of loss, which in some states, Texas included, means separating damage the covered event caused from wear and tear or earlier damage. Other states leave the cause of damage to the court.

How long does it take?

Many appraisals resolve within roughly 30 to 90 days after both appraisers are named, depending on the size of the loss, access to the property and how quickly both sides respond. The deadlines in your policy and your state's rules also apply.

Who can demand appraisal?

Under most policies either the policyholder or the insurer may demand it in writing when the parties disagree on the amount of loss. The policy and the state's rules set the details.

Before you decide anything

Is a claim stuck on the number?

Tell us what happened and where. We'll read the policy and tell you plainly whether appraisal fits.

When you write to us

  1. We read the policy, the estimates on both sides and the letters that came with them.
  2. We tell you plainly whether appraisal fits the disagreement, and if it doesn't, who can help.
  3. If it fits, we confirm next steps in writing before anything starts.